Purchase of agricultural land and pre-emption rights

When wishing to purchase agricultural land, it is necessary to pay attention to the right of pre-emption provided by law in favor of the cultivator of the land or adjacent direct cultivators. The rationale for the first scenario is to align the ownership of the land with the person who directly cultivates it. The rationale for the second case is to promote the consolidation of agricultural lands to improve the profitability of the soils and prevent excessive fragmentation of land ownership.

comp-terreni Purchase and sale of agricultural land and pre-emption
119 Purchase and sale of agricultural land and pre-emption

In both cases, the subjects holding the right must be direct cultivators: the notion is given by Art. 31 of Law 590/1965, namely someone who is "directly and habitually engaged in the cultivation of lands and the breeding and management of livestock, provided that the total labor force of the family unit is not less than one third of that required for the normal needs of the cultivation of the land and for the breeding and management of livestock." Therefore, the requirement of professionalism is not necessary: the cultivator may also engage in other jobs. In the case of livestock breeding only (pastoral land), the right of pre-emption does not exist (Cass. 2007), whereas it is admitted for forestry workers.


According to a 2007 Supreme Court ruling, a loan for use contract does not give rise to a right of pre-emption. It is necessary that the cultivators have been cultivating for at least two calendar years starting from the title. It is necessary to verify, through a land registry search, that the tenant farmer has not sold other agricultural lands with a taxable value above a certain threshold in the previous two years in order to prevent speculative activities. According to a 2006 Supreme Court decision, a suitable title is required for the management of the land: pre-emption is excluded for the tenant who has not renewed the contract, but is provided for the tenant who has the title but does not pay periodic fees. For these reasons, a retired tenant should not have the right. Problems arise in cases where there are public roads or public watercourses among the lands: according to a recent ruling (Cass. 19251/2015), "for the purposes of pre-emption and agricultural redemption, two lands are considered adjacent, even if separated by a drainage canal, when in the absence of contrary evidence it is presumed the common use of the same under Art. 897, while the relationship of physical contiguity ceases when the canal is public due to the irrigation function performed in the service of multiple lands, suitable to give it a public vocation incompatible with that of mere boundary delineation" (in the specific case, pre-emption was excluded because the canal was used by twenty-one farmers). Pre-emption exists even if there is a rural building, since it is instrumental to the exercise of agricultural activity. Conversely, when there is a construction on the land that has been registered as urban, without demonstrating the requirements of rurality, it does not fall within the scope of agricultural pre-emption as it is not instrumental to the exercise of cultivation.


If the direct cultivator tenant renounces the pre-emption, there is no pre-emption for the adjoining owners: one pre-emption consumes the other. Indeed, according to two Supreme Court rulings (6290/2003; 8369/2005), the right of pre-emption of the adjoining owner does not apply even if the direct cultivator settled on the land put up for sale has renounced the pre-emption due to him; whereas, conversely, the right of pre-emption of the adjoining owner exists in the case where the settlement of the tenant (or, in any case, a direct cultivator of the land) has, before the stipulation of the deed, lost stability as a result of an effective agreement by which the cultivator of the land being sold has committed to releasing the same land, an agreement that must, obviously, occur with the owner and be ascertained in a precise and unequivocal manner. If there is negotiation for the termination of the lease contract, no pre-emption arises in favor of the adjoining owner, with the settlement of the cultivator holding the agricultural contract persisting (Cass. 19234/2015). In the presence of multiple adjoining owners, if various theories previously existed in doctrine and jurisprudence, Legislative Decree 228/2001 has dictated specific criteria of preference in the exercise of pre-emption, namely: direct cultivators or agricultural entrepreneurs are preferred, including partnerships where the majority of the workforce is made up of direct cultivators, aged between 18 and 40 years; in subsequent order, the number of the aforementioned cultivators, provided they possess the technical knowledge required by European legislation (Regulation 1257/1999).

The size of the land does not matter as long as it is intended for agriculture. If the sale is made during the process of modifying the nature of the land, the right of pre-emption does not exist even if the process is not concluded.

Contracts that give rise to the right of pre-emption
The following onerous transfers give rise to the right of pre-emption:

  • bare ownership
  • right of redemption
  • reservation of ownership
  • public auction
  • undivided share
  • life annuity contract
  • block sale

Contracts that do not give rise to the right of pre-emption
The following do not legitimize the right of pre-emption:

  • barter
  • forced sale
  • bankruptcy
  • settlements
  • acts of gratuitous title
  • divisions, even if there is an equalization payment
  • transfers of shares of land owned by companies