Real Estate Transactions with Option Contracts
Do you want to buy a house in Mantua or Brescia but don't want to be tied to a preliminary contract because you need time to think? The option contract might be right for you. According to Art. 1331 of the Civil Code, an option exists when the parties agree that one of them remains bound by their declaration while the other has the option to accept or reject it; in such a case – as the rule states – the declaration of the first party is considered an irrevocable offer for the effects provided by Art. 1329 of the Civil Code.
The traditional view, still prevalent in jurisprudence, interprets the situation as involving a contract from which a normal contractual offer arises, accompanied – as in the case under Art. 1329 – by the prohibition for the offeror to undertake any contrary or incompatible transaction. This would involve two contracts: one (the so-called final contract), in the process of being formed, consisting at this stage only of the offer, even though it includes its essential elements; the other (the option contract), complete and perfect, aimed at making the offer irrevocable. According to another interpretation, with the option agreement, what arises is not a normal offer, but rather the power of the option holder to unilaterally determine the formation of the final contractual relationship. The final contract would therefore not be formed through the normal offer-acceptance mechanism, but through the combination of a bilateral transaction, such as the option, with the declaration of the option holder.
Once the option period expires, the offer and the option agreement are nullified, with the consequence that a late acceptance is considered a new offer by the offeree. In other words, according to the limited jurisprudence on the matter, once the agreed period has passed, the offer not only loses its irrevocability but also ceases to exist as a simple offer. The possibility of a free option contract is controversial, due to doubts that – in the absence of any consideration for the grantor – the situation should be classified as an irrevocable offer under Art. 1329. The free option may have its causal justification in the interest of the offeror in facilitating the conclusion of a contract that they are eager to enter into. Like a common offer, the declaration made binding for one of the parties by an option agreement must contain all the essential elements of the final contract in order to allow the conclusion of that contract at the time and by virtue of the other party's acceptance, without the need for further agreements; in the absence of all the elements, it is merely a preparatory agreement intended to be part of the formation process of the future contract, with the effect of fixing only the elements already agreed upon.
It is considered that the option agreement must comply with the same form as may be required for the final contract being formed. A logical consequence of the theory that reconstructs the option as a contract involving an irrevocable offer is the impossibility of its registration in public registers. From this perspective, the option contract only creates a contractual obligation and not a real right or a real constraint of unavailability; nor, on the other hand, is it considered possible to apply Art. 2645 bis of the Civil Code by analogy, because such an extension would conflict with the principle of the exhaustiveness of registrable acts. Since it is contractual in nature, and there is no reason to make an exception to the general principle, the option can certainly be agreed upon with a reservation to name the favored contracting party pursuant to Arts. 1401 et seq. of the Civil Code, as well as with effects in favor of a third party under Arts. 1411 et seq. of the Civil Code. Similarly, it is considered that the general rule of Arts. 1406 et seq. of the Civil Code applies to the assignment of the contract: the option can be assigned to third parties only with the consent (even prior) of the assigned party; more precisely, the subject of the assignment would not be the option contract itself but the final contract being formed, or the contractual offer and the right to its irrevocability.